Late-autumn meadow bordered by white pines and mostly bare hardwood trees in northern Michigan, warmed by soft afternoon light.

Suttons Bay's Next Starter Homes Are Planned for Herman Road

In October 2026, the median single-family home in Leelanau County sold for $565,000. That figure comes from 37 sales in a single month. On Herman Road in Suttons Bay Township, a three-bedroom house with a basement is planned to sell for $270,000. The land under that house will not be part of the sale.

If you're comparing Leelanau towns on a budget below the county median, the planned neighborhood at 926 and 980 S. Herman Road has published new-construction prices near the village. It also comes with a trade-off and a timeline that a portal listing would never show you.

What the Plan Puts on Herman Road

The project belongs to Peninsula Housing, a nonprofit community land trust that Leelanau wine industry veteran Larry Mawby started in 2021. Its July 17, 2026 brownfield plan describes 38 homes on about 11.39 acres in Suttons Bay Township. Right now the site has a house, a barn and two storage sheds. A trailer was torn down in 2025.

Home type Count Approx. size Planned price
Three-bedroom single-family, with basement 6 1,020 sq ft $270,000
Two-bedroom duplex unit 12 900 sq ft $225,000
One-bedroom duplex unit 6 600 sq ft $180,000
One-bedroom duplex unit 6 600 sq ft $110,000
Two-bedroom rental apartment, by Homestretch 8 487 sq ft about $2,198 a month, 2026 estimate

Peninsula Housing will build the 30 for-sale homes. Another nonprofit, Homestretch, will build the two four-unit apartment buildings. The plan puts the total cost at about $10.4 million.

Look at the sizes before the prices. The three-bedroom house is about 1,020 square feet, and the smallest rental is 487. These are compact homes. The low prices come partly from that size and mostly from how the homes are owned.

The Discount Is the Land

Peninsula Housing is a community land trust. As the Leelanau Ticker reported in August, the nonprofit sells the house and keeps ownership of the land it sits on.

That changes what a buyer is paying for. A market-rate house in Suttons Bay is a bet on land near Grand Traverse Bay and on what that land will be worth later. A Herman Road home costs less because most of that bet stays with the nonprofit. Peninsula Housing calls its model shared equity, and on its own site it describes owners selling, improving and passing on their homes. If you're weighing one of these homes against a market-rate house, get Peninsula Housing's resale terms in writing early and go over them with your own advisors.

The site also has a practical limit. Village water and sewer aren't available on Herman Road, so the plan includes wells and septic systems sized for the neighborhood. Mawby told the Leelanau Ticker in 2025 that the number of homes was set around that constraint. "This density seems to work well in the community, and it also works within our ability to provide on-site water and on-site septic," he said. Whether a parcel is inside or outside the village utility line affects Suttons Bay sales in other ways too, which we covered in The Line That Decides How Fast Your Suttons Bay Home Sells.

Built for Local Paychecks

Peninsula Housing built its Herman Road prices around local wages, not around recent lakefront sales. The brownfield plan aims the neighborhood at Leelanau County working households and sets most of the for-sale prices for buyers near the middle of the county's income range. Peninsula Housing has done this before on a smaller scale. It sold a house in Northport, bought, renovated and sold a three-bedroom home in Suttons Bay, and rents out a duplex in Lake Leelanau, according to the Leelanau Ticker. Herman Road is its first full neighborhood.

Where the Project Stands in Late November

The project has cleared several local approvals, but none of the homes is built yet. Here are the steps in order:

  • May 13, 2026: The Suttons Bay Township Board approved a new "neighborhood residential" zoning district. Peninsula Housing had requested it for the Herman Road site.
  • June 2026: The township planning commission gave the site plan preliminary approval after a public hearing, as the Leelanau Ticker reported in June.
  • July 21, 2026: The Leelanau County Brownfield Redevelopment Authority voted 6-0 to recommend the financing plan to the county board. The plan asks for $2,808,250 in tax capture over 30 years, and in August county commissioners held a training session on brownfield financing before taking up the request.
  • September 29, 2026: The planning commission gave preliminary support to Homestretch's special land use application for the apartments at 926 S. Herman Road. Homestretch would lease that parcel from Peninsula Housing for 100 years.
  • November 20, 2026: FHLBank Indianapolis set this date to announce its 2026 Affordable Housing Program awards. In June, Mawby told the Ticker that Peninsula Housing was "proceeding with our application for a major grant from the Federal Home Loan Bank" and hoped to hear in November.

If the plan stays on schedule, the first 10 for-sale homes and the eight Homestretch apartments would be finished by the end of 2027, and the other 20 homes by the end of 2029. So if you plan to move in 2026, these homes don't exist yet. If you're making a two- or three-year plan, they belong in it.

Across the Road, After 2028

Herman Road has a second site. In April 2025, the Suttons Bay Public Schools board voted to sell 9.5 acres of its athletic fields on Herman Road to Peninsula Housing for $800,000. The nonprofit partnered with the Leelanau County Land Bank Authority on the purchase. The district pays $30,000 a year to lease the fields back for three years, so development likely won't begin before 2028.

Mawby told the Ticker that early talks with the village pointed to "maybe 80 homes there, likely consisting of single-family homes and duplexes." If both sites are built out as described, the Herman Road corridor would hold more than 100 new homes priced for local paychecks.

What This Means If You're Comparing Leelanau Towns

The county median is a rough guide. Leelanau's median was $792,000 in October 2025 and $565,000 in October 2026, with 48 sales and then 37. With that few sales, one month's median can swing a long way. Across the five-county Traverse region, the year-to-date median through October 2026 was $430,000, up from $405,000 a year earlier, according to Aspire North REALTORS.

Measured against those figures, the $270,000 three-bedroom house is priced at less than half of Leelanau's October 2026 median, because the buyer pays for a house without the land. That price comes with a smaller share of whatever Suttons Bay land does next. It also comes with a wait, since the first homes are planned for late 2027. A buyer who would rather own the land outright and move sooner is shopping the regular market. If your search covers several Leelanau towns, put the Herman Road timeline next to your own move date before you rule Suttons Bay in or out. Buyers looking at market-rate homes nearby should also expect more neighbors along Herman Road. The plan calls for 38 homes on the first site, up to 80 on the second, and the wells, septic fields and landscape buffers that come with them.

FAQ

Can I buy one of these homes now? Not yet. As of mid-November 2026, Peninsula Housing's property page describes 980 Herman Road and asks interested people to contact the organization. It hasn't announced sales or a construction start.

Will the Herman Road homes be on village water and sewer? No. The plan uses on-site wells and septic systems because municipal water and sewer aren't available at the site.

Are the rentals and the for-sale homes the same project? They are on the same planned site, but two nonprofits are building them. Peninsula Housing builds the 30 for-sale homes, and Homestretch builds the eight apartments on a parcel leased from Peninsula Housing.

The prices and rents in this post come from public project plans and are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm your own situation with a lender, attorney or housing counselor before you make plans around them.

If you're deciding between a Suttons Bay home you can buy now and one that may be built on Herman Road in 2027, Team Shimek can show you what's on the market near the village today and how it compares to the land trust plan. Schedule a free consultation and we'll go through both options with you.

Pumpkin Palooza event flyer with autumn activities, an October 18 date, and RSVP QR code.

Wear Your Ugly Sweater

You're invited to Pumpkin Palooza

Work With Us

Team Shimek is a team of experienced, licensed real estate agents serving Leelanau, Grand Traverse, and Benzie Counties and the surrounding area. With a proven track record of achieving results quickly and maintaining open communication channels at all times, they are ready to help you accomplish your real estate goals!

Follow Us on Instagram